Best Italian Restaurants in San Diego 2026: The Ranked Guide
Our ranked guide to the best Italian restaurants in San Diego for 2026, from La Jolla hearth cooking at Marisi to Roman pasta at Cesarina, and how to land a table at each.
Why we wrote this guide
San Diego does Italian better than its reputation lets on, and the best rooms are spread from a La Jolla rooftop to a residential corner in Point Loma, which is exactly why picking one is hard. You have a hearth-driven coastal kitchen that swept the city's Best Italian honors, a Roman pastificio holding a Michelin Bib Gourmand, a rooftop turning out wood-fired pizza above the village, and the original wine-shop trattoria that has anchored Bankers Hill since 2009. This is our ranked guide to the best Italian restaurants in San Diego in 2026, built from the rooms our guests ask for by name. Every venue below is one we know well and send guests to. Last updated September 2026.
Looking for the table, not the reading? Tell us the night and the group and we will route you to the right room. The order below blends the quality of the kitchen with the occasion it fits best, not just the buzz around the name.
The ranked guide
1. Marisi (La Jolla)
The most decorated Italian room in the city right now. Marisi brings Italian hearth cooking to Wall Street in La Jolla Village, built on handmade pastas, classic cocktails, and fine wine, with a dining room, a dog-friendly patio, and an outdoor deck. The food is hearth-driven and ingredient-led, built around handmade pasta, from spicy rigatoni with Calabrian chilis and stracciatella to corn and crab agnolotti, plus hearth-roasted prawns and a 40-ounce bistecca alla Fiorentina. There is a setting for a quiet two-top or a celebration, and the Lemon Room for a table of your own. San Diego Magazine named it Best New Restaurant in 2023, placed it among the city's Top 5 in 2024, and crowned it Best Italian Restaurant in 2025. Reservations move quickly. See Marisi.
Best for: the special-occasion Italian dinner where the kitchen and the room both deliver.
2. Cesarina (Point Loma)
The city's Roman-pasta authority. On a residential corner in Point Loma, the restaurant named for chef Cesarina Mezzoni has held a Michelin Bib Gourmand continuously since 2021, and the defining feature is the pastificio: an open-air pasta factory where guests can watch every shape made fresh daily. The Paccheri Vodka e Scampi is the reference dish, the Polpo Croccante the near-mandatory starter, and the tableside tiramisu, made from housemade ladyfingers, espresso and mascarpone cream, is the single most-cited moment across the reviews. Book it when the pasta itself is the occasion. See Cesarina.
Best for: the pasta purist and the diner who wants Rome done properly.
3. Catania (La Jolla)
Coastal Italian with the best view on this list. Up on the third floor of the La Plaza building on the historic corner of Wall and Girard, Catania opens onto one of the finest rooftop perches in La Jolla, looking out over the village rooftops to the Pacific, and at sunset it earns its reputation as one of the most coveted reservations on the coast. The kitchen builds an authentic coastal Italian menu around Beatrice, a 5,000-pound wood-burning oven that turns out the handcrafted pizzas, from the Sicilian Pistachio with burrata and mortadella to a Wild Mushroom with garlic confit and thyme, alongside house-made pastas like the duck sugo orecchiette and ziti alla Genovese, plus a rotating crudo and the whole roasted branzino from the raw and grill side. It is listed in the Michelin Guide and was named one of Zagat's 15 hottest new restaurants in the country at launch. See Catania.
Best for: the anniversary or the sunset table with a bottle of something Sicilian.
4. Cucina Urbana (Bankers Hill)
The original, and still the most fun way to drink well over an Italian meal in the city. Cucina Urbana has anchored Bankers Hill since 2009, one of Southern California's first restaurants built around a retail wine shop, pairing Italian flavors with California seasonality, and it earned a Michelin Bib Gourmand for delivering real cooking at a fair price. The draw is the retail wine program: a shop lines one wall with 200-plus labels weighted toward Italian and California bottles, and you hand-select any one at retail price to drink with dinner for a small corkage fee. On the plate, the mascarpone-polenta meatball and the goat-cheese-stuffed squash blossoms are the long-running favorites, with brick-oven pizzas that carry playful turns like Calabrian chili crunch. See Cucina Urbana.
Best for: the group dinner that wants a great bottle without the markup, and a lively, unfussy room.
How to choose, fast
The most decorated Italian room, special occasion: Marisi.
The Roman pasta pilgrimage: Cesarina.
The sunset rooftop, view and wood-fired pizza: Catania.
The wine-shop trattoria, great value, lively group dinner: Cucina Urbana.
Why the Italian reservation is harder than it looks
The best San Diego Italian tables book up around the calendar the whole city runs on: Comic-Con International in July, Del Mar racing season, and the busy summer stretch. The rooftop sunset window at Catania, the weekend book at Cesarina, and prime-time seatings at Marisi go first. Restaurant reservations outside Las Vegas sit with the venues themselves, so book directly on each restaurant's own platform as early as the window allows.
How the booking works
Outside Las Vegas the dinner reservation sits with the restaurant, not with us.
Book the table direct on the venue's own platform - every restaurant above has its own
page carrying the current booking link - and we build the night around it.
The process for you is short:
Book the table direct. If you are not sure which room fits the night, tell us the
group and the occasion and we will tell you where to book and when the window opens.
Tell us what dinner is the anchor for: the bar before, the club after, the car
between them, the pool day the next morning.
We come back with the rest of the night, and that is the part we arrange for you.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best Italian restaurant in San Diego?
For the most decorated room right now, Marisi in La Jolla leads, named Best Italian Restaurant in San Diego for 2025 after taking Best New Restaurant in 2023 and a Top 5 finish in 2024. For Roman pasta specifically, Cesarina in Point Loma is the reference. The right answer depends on the occasion, so our ranking above goes by fit, not just reputation.
Which San Diego Italian restaurant has the best view?
Catania, on the third-floor rooftop at Wall and Girard in La Jolla, looks out over the village to the Pacific and is one of the most coveted sunset tables on the coast. Marisi's patio is the other standout setting. Book directly with the restaurant for the seating time you want.
Where should I go for the best pasta in San Diego?
Cesarina makes every shape fresh daily in an open-air pastificio, in the Roman style, with the Paccheri Vodka e Scampi as the benchmark. Marisi and Cucina Urbana both build around handmade pasta as well. For the purist pasta night, Cesarina is the pick.
Which San Diego Italian spots hold a Michelin Bib Gourmand?
Cesarina has held the Bib Gourmand continuously since 2021, and Cucina Urbana carries it as well. Catania is listed in the Michelin Guide. Marisi has swept San Diego Magazine's Italian honors.
How far in advance should I book?
For a standard weekend dinner, a week or two is usually enough, and Cesarina in particular books out quickly for Saturday. For Comic-Con week, Del Mar season, or a peak summer weekend, plan two to six weeks ahead, especially for the Catania sunset window.
Booking the table
Book the table direct on the restaurant's own platform - each pick above links to its
page with the current booking link. Then tell us the night and the group and we will
build the rest of it around dinner.
Build a plan with us
Want the full lineup? Browse every San Diego restaurant we feature to round out the trip.
Build a custom itinerary with our concierge team. Pair the venues mentioned above into a single concierge-confirmed evening. See the full Las Vegas events calendar for every upcoming DJ and pool party across the city.
Keep reading
Plan a night in another city
Browse all MyRSVP editorials · Back to home