The Best Italian Restaurants in New York (2026)
A concierge-ranked guide to the best Italian restaurants in New York for 2026 - from Carbone's red-sauce theater to Michelin-starred pasta rooms - each bookable and ready to anchor your night.
The best Italian restaurants in New York in 2026 span two traditions that rarely sit at the same table: tuxedoed, red-sauce theater rooms and the old Village institutions, and a newer wave of pasta rooms where a single handmade shape can define a chef's reputation. Below is our concierge team's ranked shortlist of the best Italian restaurants in NYC - the ones we hand to guests who want the dinner to be the event, not the warm-up. Each links straight to its MyRSVP page for hours, signature dishes, and how to reserve.
A note on how we work: outside Las Vegas, we concentrate on nightclub and pool-club bookings, not restaurant reservations. So treat this as a concierge city guide - the rooms, the dishes, the timing - and the fastest route to your own table. Many of our guests pair one of these dinners with a MyRSVP nightlife booking elsewhere in the city.
1. Carbone
No restaurant reset the category the way Carbone did. Chefs Mario Carbone and Rich Torrisi's Greenwich Village red-sauce icon turned mid-century Italian-American into a full-blown spectacle - captains in Zac Posen tuxedos, the Caesar alla ZZ, and a dining room that feels like a party every single night. The spicy rigatoni vodka is the most photographed pasta in the city for good reason, and the veal parmesan and Mario's meatballs hold up the theater around it. It is the hardest of these tables to land and the one out-of-towners plan the whole trip around. Book it for the big night when you want the restaurant to be the headline.
2. Torrisi
Torrisi is a one-Michelin-star Italian-American room inside the landmark Puck Building in Nolita, and it is the more refined sibling to Carbone's roar. Waiters in dinner jackets, pressed linens, and a buzzy hum set the tone; chef Rich Torrisi reworks familiar dishes - tuna with pickled caponata, penne with baby chanterelles, tortellini pomodoro - with real polish. Finish with the affogato, which arrives in an oversized martini glass. Reservations open 30 days out on Resy for parties up to six, and the Bar Counter takes walk-ins first come, first served. This is the occasion room for a well-dressed downtown night.
3. Rezdora
Rezdora is the cult Emilia-Romagna pasta room that obsessives cross the city for - a one-Michelin-star osteria in the Flatiron from chef Stefano Secchi, who trained across Modena before opening it. The regional pasta tasting is the marquee move, a guided run through the anolini di Parma, gramigna with slow-braised sausage ragu, and the green cappelletti with roasted leeks that show off technique over flash. The room is warm, low-lit, and buzzy, with tables running close. Reservations run on SevenRooms and fill fast, so target an off-peak weekday if prime slots are gone. If you rank New York's best Italian restaurants by pasta alone, Rezdora is near the very top.
4. Lilia
Lilia is Missy Robbins' pasta flagship in a converted Williamsburg auto-body shop, and since 2016 it has been one of the single hardest tables in the city. Two dishes carry the reputation: the mafaldini, ruffled ribbons in a pink peppercorn and Parmesan sauce, and the sheep's-milk agnolotti with saffron. Robbins works a wood-fired grill as hard as the pasta station, so open with the grilled clams and cherry tomato focaccia. It does not hold a Michelin star, but it earned three New York Times stars and won Robbins the James Beard Best Chef award - a signal of pure consistency. Tables for up to six book on Resy, and slots move fast.
5. Don Angie
Don Angie is the West Village's cult modern Italian-American, opened by married chefs Angie Rito and Scott Tacinelli in a jewel-box corner room. The headliner is the Lasagna for Two, a pinwheel-rolled showpiece of Italian sausage bolognese and whipped robiolina that launched a thousand posts and remains the reason many guests book at all. Around it, the chrysanthemum salad, stuffed garlic flatbread, and garganelli with broken-meatball ragu tell an American story through an Italian lens. It held a Michelin star in 2021 and 2022 but no longer carries one, so we list it on the strength of the cooking. Book through OpenTable, and expect prime slots to vanish quickly.
6. L'Artusi
L'Artusi has been a West Village mainstay since 2008, and after almost two decades the two-floor room still fills the moment doors open at 5 p.m. It is the modern-Italian, pasta-and-wine evening that anchors a night out. Executive chef Joe Vigorito builds around house-made pasta - tagliatelle bolognese bianco, bucatini with pancetta and tomato, and the long-standing spaghetti with garlic, chilies, and sourdough breadcrumbs - backed by an Italian wine list that runs deep across every region. Save room for the olive oil cake. Reservations release on a two-week rolling basis at 9 a.m. on Resy, with walk-in bar and counter seats held first-come. One of the most reliably great Italian restaurants in New York for a spontaneous, low-drama dinner.
7. Scarpetta
Scarpetta opened in the Meatpacking District in 2008 and has been settled on Madison Avenue, inside the Hotel Seville in NoMad, since 2018. The spaghetti with tomato and basil is what most people book for - four ingredients described so plainly on the menu that first-timers underestimate it, and one of the few pasta plates in New York that people order before they have opened the menu. The rest follows the same logic: handmade pasta, a short list of things done properly, and a dining room that runs formal without being stiff. It also takes lunch as seriously as dinner, which along this stretch of Manhattan is rarer than it should be. If Las Vegas is the next stop, Scarpetta at the Cosmopolitan is the same kitchen, and our Las Vegas team can book that one.
8. Marea
Marea is the upscale Italian seafood room on Central Park South, and for coastal, produce-forward cooking it is in a class of its own among New York's Italian restaurants. The signature is the fusilli with red wine-braised octopus and bone marrow - a dish regulars have ordered for years - alongside a crudo program and a deep raw bar that lean fully into the sea. The room is polished and grown-up, built for a special dinner, not a scene, and the setting overlooking the park makes it a natural anchor for a big evening. Book it when you want the refinement of a Midtown occasion room with the pasta pedigree to match.
9. Cafe Carmellini
Cafe Carmellini was one of the city's biggest openings of 2023-24: chef Andrew Carmellini's grand Italian-French flagship inside The Fifth Avenue Hotel in NoMad. The Martin Brudnizki-designed room is a maximalist showpiece - double-height ceilings, sculptural trees, sapphire-blue velvet booths - and the cooking distills a 30-year New York career into signatures like the lobster cannelloni della casa, squab en croute, and Atlantic halibut with an osetra caviar supplement. It is a MICHELIN Guide listing, though not a starred restaurant. Reservations are exclusively on Resy, open four weeks in advance. Book this for the anniversary, the deal dinner, or the first big night out in the city.
10. Il Mulino New York
Il Mulino New York is the old-guard Greenwich Village institution, open at the same address since 1981. This is not a scene chasing the moment; it is a brick-walled classic built for an unhurried, abundant dinner. The meal starts before you order, with a parade of complimentary antipasti - salumi, marinated mussels, hunks of Parmigiano-Reggiano cut from a large wheel - and the kitchen builds outward from there with handmade pastas and plates that draw on both land and sea. It does not hold a Michelin star; its reputation rests on longevity and generosity. Book on Resy, and expect old-school, theatrical service. The pick for the guest who wants abundance over minimalism.
11. Sartiano's
Sartiano's is Scott Sartiano's see-and-be-seen Italian inside the Mercer Hotel, and the SoHo table of the moment. The Studio Sofield room feels like a moody Tuscan wine cellar dressed for a downtown crowd - Carrara marble bar, deep leather banquettes, a steady fashion-world clientele. Under culinary director Alfred Portale, the pastas are the signatures: lobster bucatini with Calabrian chili butter, a wild mushroom and black truffle lasagna, and fusilli with Wagyu beef ragu. Reservations run through SevenRooms, and dinner slots are hard to land, so brunch and lunch are the calmer way in. Rank it here for the guest who wants the dinner to double as the scene.
Booking the night
Dinner reservations at every restaurant above run directly through the venue - Resy, SevenRooms, or OpenTable, linked on each MyRSVP page along with hours, dress codes, and the exact booking windows. Where we take over is the rest of the night. Outside Las Vegas our concierge specializes in nightclub and pool-club bookings, so once your table is set, submit the MyRSVP form on the nightlife venue you are planning around and a concierge assigned to that room will follow up with pricing, placement, and the best area for your group. Build the evening around one of the best Italian restaurants in New York, and let us handle where you go after.
Build a custom itinerary with our concierge team. Pair the venues mentioned above into a single concierge-confirmed evening. See the full Las Vegas events calendar for every upcoming DJ and pool party across the city.
Keep reading
- Best Japanese Restaurants in London 2026: Sushi, Robata and Nikkei · The best Japanese and Nikkei restaurants in London for 2026, from Zuma and Roka to Nobu and Sushisamba, ranked and bookable with MyRSVP.
- Best Nightclubs in London 2026: The Bottle-Service and VIP-Table Guide · The 9 best London nightclubs for bottle service in 2026, ranked by room, music policy, and who each is for - with our London partner booking the table directly.
- The Best Restaurants in Mayfair 2026 · A ranked guide to the best Mayfair restaurants for 2026, from three-Michelin-star tasting menus to the buzzy dining rooms that define London's most glamorous square mile.
- The Best Restaurants in London 2026 · The definitive ranked guide to the best restaurants in London for 2026 - from three-Michelin-star icons to the marquee scene rooms that define a night out.
- Best Restaurants in New York (2026): The 13 Best Tables Across Every Cuisine · Our concierge shortlist of the 13 best restaurants in New York for 2026 - three-Michelin-star tasting temples, iconic scene tables, definitive steakhouses, and the Korean rooms remaking the city.
- Best Rooftop Bars in New York (2026): The 12 Best Skyline, Date-Night, and Party Roofs · Our concierge shortlist of the 12 best rooftop bars in New York for 2026, grouped by vibe - head-on skyline views, romantic date-night lounges, and all-in party roofs.
Plan a night in another city
Browse all MyRSVP editorials · Back to home